Prosecutor Justin Lewis had requested the 12 jurors to contemplate that Leifer, a Tel Aviv-born mom of eight, confirmed sexual curiosity within the ladies after they had been teenage college students on the college and later after they turned pupil academics there. He alleged that Leifer engaged in sexual actions with them and took benefit of their vulnerability and ignorance in sexual issues, and her place of authority.
The sisters had an remoted upbringing within the ultra-Orthodox Jewish neighborhood and acquired no sexual training, the court docket heard. They had been aged round 12, 14 and 16 when Leifer arrived on the college from Israel in 2001.
Lewis stated the sisters had supplied specific proof that they didn’t perceive the sexual nature of what Leifer did to them. The abuse allegedly occurred in school camps and through non-public classes on Sundays on the college and Leifer’s dwelling.
Leifer allegedly abused the eldest sister whereas they shared a mattress at a college camp as the center sibling pretended to be asleep in the identical room. Jurors had been instructed the youngest sibling had walked right into a room whereas Leifer was abusing the oldest sister.
“Mrs. Leifer was one of the vital revered individuals locally. If Mrs. Leifer was doing one thing then it should be okay,” the youngest sibling testified about her response to what she noticed occurring to her sister.
The center sister instructed the jury she had tried to type a relationship with one other trainer to ask about what Leifer was doing, however Leifer discouraged her. Leifer “instructed me it wasn’t wholesome for me to have a reference to one other trainer, to have a couple of mentor,” the center sister testified.
The sisters gave proof over two weeks behind closed doorways, with the general public and media excluded in keeping with guidelines governing sexual assault trials in Victoria.
Different witnesses included these the sisters disclosed their allegations to.
The center sister first spoke to social employee Chana Rabinowitz in Israel in early 2008. Rabinowitz stated she requested the sister who harm her and the younger girl replied “it was Mrs. Leifer.”
Psychologist Vicki Gordon testified that she heard the youngest sister declare abuse by Leifer. Gordon instructed the court docket the sister claimed Leifer had defined the abuse was an try to beat a scarcity of heat and affection within the ladies’ household life.
Leifer’s lawyer Ian Hill instructed the jury the sisters had revered Leifer and writings from their college years confirmed them thanking her for being supportive. Hill stated the center sister’s story had modified a number of occasions because the allegations had been made in 2008.
“Reality and reliability had been misplaced in false accounts,” Hill stated. “Even perhaps at occasions hardened into false imaginations and false recollections of false realities.”
He criticized the youngest sister for altering the situation of alleged incidents from the ladies’ hometown of Melbourne to Israel.
“It’s the flawed reminiscence mixed with the element that reveals you simply how harmful some witnesses might be when recounting a story to you,” Hill stated.
She had initially confronted 29 expenses. However two indecency expenses relating to highschool play rehearsals had been dropped in the course of the trial as a result of the incidents had been alleged to have occurred earlier than a related regulation got here into impact in 2006.